Patty Melts Creamy Sauce

When slow-cooked onions blend with sizzling beef, you'll get a patty melt that makes restaurant versions look sad in comparison. I tweaked this recipe for years in my kitchen, adjusting every part until the mix of buttery grilled rye, melty cheese, and juicy beef hit absolute greatness. Making these at home turns a normal weeknight meal into something really special, believe me.

Must-Have Ingredients

Ground Beef: Talk to your butcher and ask for fresh 80/20 beef. Those fat streaks mean your patty melt will be juicy and packed with flavor.

Rye Bread: Don't bother with packaged slices - go to a real bakery. Find a loaf that feels heavy with little caraway seeds throughout. Good bread makes all the difference.

Swiss and Cheddar: Don't go cheap here. I learned this the hard way after my budget cheese turned into a rubbery mess instead of getting all gooey.

Onions: Pick firm yellow onions with some weight to them. Their outer skin should make noise when you squeeze them gently.

I still remember watching my grandma cut paper-thin onion slices for her amazing patty melts. She always said the thinner you slice them, the sweeter they get. Now I hear her words every time I'm slicing onions in my kitchen.

Save

Step-by-Step Creation Process

Whip Up The Sauce:

Combine mayo with enough ketchup to make it slightly orange. Throw in some sweet pickle relish - my grandma never told anyone about this ingredient. Add a splash of Worcestershire sauce and mix until you've got a smooth, tangy spread that'll wake up your taste buds.

Transform The Onions:

Start with butter in a cold, heavy pan. When it starts bubbling, add those super-thin onion slices. Keep the heat low-medium. Don't rush this part - you want that deep golden color that means they've turned sweet and soft.

Handle The Meat:

Just add salt and pepper to your beef. Shape patties a bit bigger than your bread since they'll shrink while cooking. Push your thumb into the middle of each one. An old chef taught me this stops them from puffing up in the middle.

Cook To Perfection:

Get your cast iron nice and hot - a water droplet should bounce when it hits the surface. Put those seasoned patties down and wait for that wonderful sizzle. Let them form a nice crust before you flip them. About four minutes each side will get you a perfect medium-rare.

Stack Everything Up:

Butter your rye bread heavily - don't hold back here. Start with Swiss cheese, add your hot patty, pile on those golden onions, and top with sharp chedder. Finish with the second slice of buttered rye.

Grill To Finish:

Back in the pan they go. Keep heat at medium - we want the bread to turn golden while the cheese gets all melty. Press down lightly with your spatula, just enough to help everything stick together into sandwich heaven.

Tasty Side Options

A crunchy dill pickle adds the right zingy bite alongside your patty melt. For sides, I can't resist serving these with either rosemary-tossed homemade fries or a sharp vinegar coleslaw that helps cut through all that richness.

Customize It

Sometimes I switch out the Swiss for smoked gouda, or toss in some cooked mushrooms with the onions. For a lighter version, turkey works great, though you'll still want some fat for flavor. During summer, I might slip in a thin slice of garden-fresh tomato.

Save

Storage Solutions

These sandwiches taste best right off the stove, but if you have extras, wrap them loosely in foil and warm them in a 300-degree oven. The low heat keeps the bread crispy while gently warming everything inside.

Pro Kitchen Wisdom

Always let your cheese sit out until it reaches room temp before using it - it'll melt way better.

Don't forget to butter the bread's outside - that's what gives you that amazing golden crust.

Take your patties out of the fridge about 20 minutes before cooking for the most even results.

You know what I've realized after making these for years? A patty melt isn't just food - it's like sharing love on a plate. Whenever I make them, whether for family dinner or hanging out with friends, people come together. The talking slows down, phones disappear, and everyone just enjoys that perfect comfort food moment.

Recipe FAQs

→ Can I switch to another bread?

Sure, sourdough or wheat works if you don't have rye.

→ What do caramelized onions look like?

They turn soft, golden-brown, and take about 15-20 minutes to cook.

→ Can I prepare the sauce in advance?

Yes, it’ll stay good in the fridge for up to 3 days.

→ Which ground beef tastes best?

Go with an 80/20 ratio for juicy patties packed with flavor.

→ How can I make these lighter?

Sub in turkey or chicken and opt for low-fat cheese.