Save
I found this DIY Starbucks pumpkin spice sauce last autumn when my daily PSL cravings were quickly emptying my wallet. Whipping it up at home has totally changed the game, both for my budget and because I can adjust the sweetness exactly how I like it!
My sis, a total pumpkin spice fanatic, actually told me she likes my homemade version better than the coffee shop's now. That moment convinced me this recipe was something special!
Ingredients You'll Want
- Condensed milk: This is the key ingredient many copycat versions leave out! It gives that smooth richness that makes the Starbucks sauce so tempting.
- Pumpkin puree: Grab pure pumpkin puree only, not the pie filling stuff that's already got spices and sweeteners mixed in.
- Sugar: Forms the base that'll blend perfectly into hot beverages.
- Pumpkin pie spice: The classic autumn flavor mix. You can buy it ready-made or throw together your own blend.
- Water: Basic but crucial for getting the texture just right.
Save
My Cooking Method
Sugar Syrup BaseI begin with a simple mix of equal sugar and water portions. Going slow with low heat is crucial - trying to rush will just cause sugar crystals. I can tell it's ready when the mixture turns from cloudy to completely clear.
Adding The PumpkinMixing in pumpkin puree while the syrup's still warm helps everything blend better. I always use a whisk to break up any sneaky lumps hiding in there.
Adding CreaminessThe real transformation happens once you stir in condensed milk - it changes from watery syrup into that thick, velvety sauce that sticks to your spoon. This creates the rich texture we all crave in a PSL.
Proper StorageI put the hot sauce straight into a glass container, then let it cool down fully before putting it in the fridge. This stops moisture from gathering inside which might make it spoil faster.
I learned how important condensed milk is after trying many disappointing recipes that were basically just sugary pumpkin water. The first time I added condensed milk to my batch, it felt like I'd cracked the secret Starbucks code!
Ways To Use It
This sauce works great for homemade pumpkin spice lattes of course, but you can do so much more with it. I love adding it to hot chai for a pumpkin chai latte, pouring it over plain ice cream, or using it on top of breakfast foods like pancakes. For an evening treat, mix some bourbon with your coffee and this sauce!
Personalize Your Sauce
Adjust the spices to match what you love - more cinnamon makes it warmer, extra ginger adds kick, or try a bit of cardamom for something different. Want it less sweet? Cut the sugar by up to 25%. Going dairy-free? Try coconut condensed milk instead of regular (just know it'll add a slight coconut taste).
Keeping It Fresh
This sauce stays good in your fridge for around 3 weeks if kept in a sealed container. All that sugar naturally helps it last longer. You can also freeze little portions in ice cube trays, then bag the frozen cubes for quick single servings that last for months.
Save
Expert Advice
- For the silkiest texture, give the finished sauce a quick blend with a stick blender
- Heat your sauce slightly before adding to cold coffee drinks so it mixes better
- Using a mason jar with a pump makes adding sauce to drinks much cleaner and easier
Making my own pumpkin spice sauce has totally changed my fall coffee habits. Instead of dropping $6 every day at Starbucks, I can make the perfect PSL at home super cheaply. And there's something really satisfying about seeing that jar of amber gold waiting in my fridge each morning. It's become an autumn tradition I can't wait for each year!
Recipe FAQs
- → How long will this sauce last in the fridge?
- It’ll stay fresh for about 2 weeks if stored in a sealed container. The sugar and condensed milk help preserve it.
- → Can this work in both hot and cold drinks?
- Absolutely! It’s great in both warm lattes and iced drinks. For cold ones, mix it with a bit of hot water first so it blends easier.
- → What’s a substitute for pumpkin pie spice?
- Stir together 1/4 tsp cinnamon, 1/8 tsp ginger, a pinch of nutmeg, and a tiny bit of allspice or cloves to make a quick version.
- → How do I make this less sweet?
- Use 1/4 cup sugar instead. But remember, the condensed milk also adds sweetness and creaminess, so it’ll still be slightly sweet.
- → How much of this mix should I use per cup?
- For a 12 to 16 oz latte, add 3-4 tbsp of sauce. Adjust up or down based on how sweet or pumpkin-y you like your drink.
Favorite fall coffee mix
A fast and simple take on Starbucks' iconic pumpkin spice sauce. Perfect for autumn coffees or teas, ready to enjoy quickly!
Ingredients
→ Syrup Base
→ Spices
Steps
Dump the sugar and water into a small saucepan. Let it heat over medium, giving it an occasional stir until the sugar melts and it starts to bubble lightly.
When the mixture starts boiling, lower the heat to keep it from burning or evaporating too much.
Now add the puree, condensed milk, salt, and pumpkin spice mix to the saucepan. Stir it all together until it’s mixed well.
Let the mixture cook on low for another minute or two while stirring. You want it smooth, warmed through, and nice and blended.
Take it off the heat and let it cool down fully. Once it’s no longer warm, pour it into a jar or any container with a lid. Stick it in the fridge, and it’ll keep fresh for up to 14 days.
Notes
- This batch makes 40 tablespoons of syrup, which is enough for around 10 drinks using 4 tablespoons each.
- To make a pumpkin latte, mix 4 tablespoons of this syrup into a mug of hot coffee or chai tea, then top off with frothed milk.
- Once refrigerated, the sauce will thicken a bit. It’ll loosen right up when stirred into something hot.
Required Tools
- Small pot
- Spoon or whisk for combining ingredients
- Measuring spoons and cups
- Jar with lid for storing
Allergy Information
Check each ingredient for potential allergens and consult a healthcare professional if needed.
- Includes dairy from condensed milk
Nutritional Facts (per serving)
These details are provided for informational purposes and aren't a substitute for medical advice.
- Calories: 68
- Fats: 1.5 g
- Carbohydrates: 11.7 g
- Proteins: 1.6 g