Comforting Mushroom Chicken Bake

Featured in Dinner Solutions You'll Love.

Savory chicken bake with a creamy mushroom sauce and cheesy finish. Serves 6 in about an hour. Great for weeknight comfort.
Rose
Updated on Mon, 17 Mar 2025 00:32:16 GMT
Chicken bake topped with mushrooms Pin it
Chicken bake topped with mushrooms | tastybysophie.com

Born out of need but fine-tuned with affection - that's what Chicken Gloria is all about. This homemade version, featuring a smooth mushroom cream sauce and beautifully melted cheese, turns basic chicken into something really special. Whenever I cook it, my kitchen fills with the wonderful smells of sherry and garlic that promise pure comfort.

I made this for guests a few weeks ago. Everyone went quiet except for the noise of forks clearing plates. That's always a good sign you've got something fantastic.

Key Ingredients

  • Whole Mushrooms: Cremini for richer taste
  • Quality Sherry: Skip the grocery store cooking wine
  • Full Cream: This isn't the place to cut calories
  • Tasty Cheese: Try Muenster or Swiss varieties
  • Real Garlic: The jarred stuff won't work here
Chicken Gloria Recipe Pin it
Chicken Gloria Recipe | tastybysophie.com

Making The Dish

First Steps:
Cut your chicken pieces to the same thickness - this really matters. Season them well and coat in flour. When I first tried making this, I skipped the flour part. Bad move - it's what gives you that nice golden outside and helps thicken everything up later.
Getting That Color:
Make sure your pan is seriously hot - you want to hear that chicken sizzle when it touches the surface. Don't crowd the pan; work in smaller batches. I've learned not to poke at it too soon - when it's ready to turn, it'll come off the pan easily.
Mushroom Goodness:
All those tasty bits left from cooking chicken become the base for your mushrooms. Let them turn golden and smell amazing. If your kitchen doesn't smell fantastic at this point, something's wrong.
Building Your Sauce:
This part needs a bit of time. Pour in sherry first and let it bubble down a little - watch those amazing smells fill your kitchen. Then add cream, which turns everything into a velvety dream.

My mother called me just days ago saying she'd dreamed about this meal. That's what truly good comfort food does - it sticks in your memory.

Delicious Companions

To round out your meal:

  • Buttery egg noodles catch all the sauce
  • Oven-roasted green beans for freshness and snap
  • Fresh bread for wiping plates clean
  • Simple green salad cuts through the richness
  • Nice white wine (something you'd happily drink)

Keeping It Fresh

  • Stays good 3-4 days in covered container
  • Warm up slowly to keep sauce smooth
  • Tastes better warmed in oven than zapped
  • Can prep ahead up to final baking
  • Cream sauce texture changes if frozen
Best Chicken Gloria Recipe Pin it
Best Chicken Gloria Recipe | tastybysophie.com

Common Questions

Can I swap out the mushrooms?
Sure thing - try portobellos or wild mushroom mix for a twist.
Don't have any sherry?
Marsala or a dry white wine works too, but sherry gives that special flavor.
Want to prep it early?
Put everything together up to 24 hours ahead, let it warm up before cooking.

This Chicken Gloria has become what I cook for everything from family Sunday meals to when the in-laws visit. It shows how basic ingredients can turn into something amazing with just a bit of care and time.

It doesn't matter if you're feeding two people or ten, this meal hits that sweet spot between homey and fancy. And those crunchy cheese bits around the edges? They're your reward as the cook - perfect for snacking while you serve.

Just remember, a good sauce is worth everything, and this one's absolute gold.

Mushroom Chicken Bake

Juicy chicken in a velvety mushroom sauce, topped with bubbly cheese. An easy homemade treat for the family.

Prep Time
15 Minutes
Cook Time
45 Minutes
Total Time
60 Minutes

Category: Main Dishes

Difficulty: Intermediate

Cuisine: American

Yield: 6 Servings

Dietary: ~

Ingredients

→ Chicken Prep

01 6 thinly sliced chicken breast halves
02 A sprinkle of salt and pepper
03 A spoonful of olive oil
04 Some flour for coating

→ Sauce Details

05 8 ounces of sliced cremini mushrooms
06 2 minced garlic cloves
07 4 tablespoons of butter (use 2 now, 2 later)
08 Two tablespoons of plain flour
09 Half a cup of dry sherry wine
10 1 and a half cups of heavy cream

→ Cheesy Topping

11 6 slices of Muenster cheese

Instructions

Step 01

Adjust oven rack near top and set to 375°F. Slice chicken to make six pieces. Add some salt and pepper, then dust with flour.

Step 02

Warm oil and butter (1 tablespoon) in a large pan. Cook chicken until golden, 3-4 minutes each side, working in batches. Move to a casserole dish.

Step 03

In the same pan, add butter (1 tablespoon) and cook mushrooms for about 5 minutes until browned and dry. Put them with the chicken.

Step 04

Melt remaining butter in the skillet. Stir in flour and garlic, cooking for a minute. Pour in sherry and whisk in cream, letting it thicken slightly.

Step 05

Pour sauce over chicken and mushrooms in casserole. Lay cheese on top, cover with foil, and bake for 20 minutes. Remove foil and broil for a golden top.

Notes

  1. Feel free to swap Muenster for Swiss, Gruyere, or mozzarella.
  2. Try Marsala wine if sherry isn’t handy.

Tools You'll Need

  • Casserole dish (9x13)
  • Big skillet
  • Whisk
  • Foil for covering

Allergy Information

Please check ingredients for potential allergens and consult a health professional if in doubt.
  • Includes dairy (cheese, butter, cream)
  • Contains gluten (due to flour)

Nutrition Facts (Per Serving)

It is important to consider this information as approximate and not to use it as definitive health advice.
  • Calories: 568
  • Total Fat: 43 g
  • Total Carbohydrate: 8 g
  • Protein: 33 g