Pin it
I whipped up these rainbow-filled sandwich treats for my niece's special day, and now they're the dessert everyone begs me to bring. There's something truly special about cookies packed with colorful sprinkles hugging a smooth frosting middle that makes folks smile at parties. The mix of soft, buttery cookies with that hint of almond flavor plus the tangy cream cheese filling hits all the right notes. Though they look fancy and fun, you won't struggle much making them – just don't forget about the time needed for cooling the dough!
When I brought a batch to my buddy's new place last month, her little girl took one bite and told everyone at the party they were "the best cookies in the universe." Her mom sent me a message later saying her daughter asked every single day when they could make "those sprinkle sandwich things" again. That's exactly the kind of magic these cookies bring!
Key Ingredients
- Almond flour - This makes all the difference for that melt-away softness. The cookies keep their shape while baking but stay wonderfully soft when you bite into them. Got nut allergies? You can swap in more regular flour, but they'll feel a bit different in your mouth.
- Sprinkles - These little guys steal the show! Go for the longer stick-shaped ones instead of the tiny balls because they won't bleed color into your dough as badly. They'll stay bright and pretty throughout baking.
- Clear vanilla extract - This keeps your dough looking white so your sprinkles really pop. Regular brown vanilla works fine for taste, but if you want them to look amazing, grab the clear stuff.
- Cream cheese - This turns your filling from basic to amazing. Let it sit out until it's completely soft to avoid lumps. The full-fat kind gives the richest taste, but light cream cheese works in a pinch.
- Almond extract - Just a tiny bit adds something special that works so well with the vanilla. You can skip it if needed, but it gives that fancy bakery taste that makes people ask for your secret.
Pin it
Baking Tricks
- Getting the dough right:
- Watch how the dough feels as you mix. It should be a bit sticky but not glue your fingers together. If it's too sticky, add a spoon of flour at a time until it feels right. Don't go overboard with flour or your cookies will end up tough.
- Smart rolling method:
- The game-changer is using plastic wrap both below and on top of your dough. This stops sticking without needing loads of flour that can toughen your cookies. Keep the thickness at 1/4-inch for that perfect bite – too thin and they'll snap instead of being soft.
- The waiting game:
- You really must chill the dough! Two hours minimum, but leaving it overnight works great if you want to get ahead. Cold dough keeps its shape when baking and tastes better too. If your cut shapes start warming up and getting floppy, stick them in the freezer for 10 minutes.
- Watch the clock:
- Pull these out when they're just barely golden at the edges and look slightly undercooked in the middle. They'll finish baking from the hot pan's heat. This slight underbaking keeps them soft enough for sandwiching.
- Putting them together:
- For the neatest look, pipe frosting in a ring near the edge of the bottom cookie, leaving a tiny border. When you press the top cookie down, the filling will spread perfectly without oozing out the sides.
My first try at these taught me a few things the hard way. I rushed and didn't chill the dough long enough, so my cookies spread out and lost their cute shapes. I've also played around with different amounts of filling and found that you want just the right balance – too much squishes out messily, too little makes the sandwich feel dry.
Display Ideas
Make these funfetti sandwich cookies even more wow-worthy by stacking them on a tiered stand for birthday parties. Match your sprinkle colors to your event – holiday red and green, your favorite team's colors, or soft pastels for baby celebrations. They make wonderful gifts wrapped in pretty containers with parchment between layers. Want a summer twist? Skip the frosting and use a small scoop of vanilla ice cream between two cookies instead.
Tasty Twists
Once you get the hang of the basic version, get creative! Add a pinch of lemon or orange zest to your cookie dough for a fresh twist. Try mini chocolate chips instead of sprinkles for a different but equally yummy cookie. Use fun cookie cutters rather than circles – hearts for love day, stars for summer cookouts. Add a tiny drop of food coloring to your filling to match your party theme. During winter holidays, mix a hint of peppermint into your frosting for a festive flavor.
Keeping Them Fresh
These colorful sandwich cookies stay perfect for about five days when kept in a sealed container in your fridge. They actually taste even better the next day as the flavors mix together. Need to make them way ahead? You can freeze the finished cookies for up to three months – just let them thaw in the fridge for a few hours before serving. You can also freeze just the plain cookies and add filling later when you're ready.
Pin it
I've baked these colorful sandwich cookies for tons of birthdays, baby parties, and just-because gatherings. Something about how fun they look and their perfect flavor combo makes them right for almost any happy occasion. While they might seem fancy, the steps are simple enough for anyone to follow. The extra time for chilling and putting them together is totally worth it when you see how happy people get when they take that first bite!
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can these cookies be made ahead?
- Absolutely! The dough stays good in the fridge for up to three days. Baked cookies last in a container for 2-3 days. Once filled, enjoy them within five days and keep them refrigerated.
- → What if almond flour isn’t available?
- No worries! Swap out the almond flour (1/3 cup) for 1/4 cup of additional plain flour. The result is slightly less tender but still tasty.
- → Which sprinkles should I use?
- Jimmies (long sprinkles) work best since they don’t run into the dough. Nonpareils (small ones) can bleed, so mix them carefully to avoid streaks.
- → Why is chilling the dough important?
- It firms up the butter and keeps the cookies from spreading too much. Chilling also improves cutting precision and lets the flour fully absorb moisture.
- → Is freezing these cookies an option?
- Yep! Freeze the unbaked dough for up to three months or bake and freeze cookies without filling for two months. Thaw and frost just before serving.
- → What size cutter works best?
- A 2-inch round cutter gives ideal results, but you can play with other shapes too. Baking time will change based on size—smaller cookies need less time, bigger ones might need a bit more.