Cream Pie Croissants

I whipped up Boston Cream Pie Croissants one gloomy Sunday when I'd promised my kids a special breakfast but completely blanked on planning. I found some croissants sitting in the bread drawer from yesterday and spotted pudding cups in the fridge. After playing around for about 20 minutes, these treats were created - and now they're what everyone asks for whenever family drops by.

When my sister-in-law watched me make these last month, she kept asking "that's ALL?" with growing surprise as I showed her each step. She always makes everything from the ground up, so when she grudgingly admitted these were "actually amazing," I felt like I'd won a gold medal in baking.

Basic Ingredients

• Pre-made croissants: Try to get ones from your grocery's bakery area, but the packaged kind will do just fine when you're in a hurry
• Light cream: I've tried half & half, heavy cream, and sometimes just whole milk when the fridge was running low (cream does make a tastier custard though)
• Egg yolks: Keep the whites for tomorrow's omelet, or if you're feeling extra, whip up some meringue cookies while your custard gets cold
• Quality chocolate: This is where it's worth spending a bit more since you'll really taste the chocolate, but I've totally used chocolate chips many times when that's all I had
• Nuts for topping: Any kind works! I've thrown on everything from fancy green pistachios to whatever mixed nuts were left from holiday baking

Pin it

Simple Preparation

Making Holes

Poke into your croissants with a wooden skewer or even a chopstick. Don't worry about getting it perfect - just wiggle around inside to create room for filling. My first try was too careful and hardly any custard got in. Now I really hollow them out. Sometimes bits of butter fall out during this - consider it your cook's treat.

Creating Custard

Mix those yolks, sugar, cornstarch and salt thoroughly - get everything smooth before adding any liquid. I used to hurry this part and always got tiny cornstarch clumps that bugged me. Add the cream gradually while whisking constantly. When cooking, stay right there and keep stirring. The first time, I checked a text while stirring and came back to egg scramble. Now I know custard needs full attention.

Adding Butter

Put in those butter cubes one by one, letting each one melt before adding another. This step seems like extra work until you taste what it does - the custard changes from good to incredibly silky and rich. Once I dumped all the butter in at once when my toddler started crying, and while it eventually melted okay, the texture wasn't quite as smooth. The vanilla goes in at the end - I learned this after adding it too early once and watching my beautiful custard turn into weird grainy bits.

Stuffing Croissants

If you don't have a real piping bag, a ziplock with the corner cut works just as well. I've even used a turkey baster when desperate! Fill from both openings until you feel pushback or see custard starting to leak out. The first batch, I overfilled them badly and custard exploded all over my counter. Now I know a little less filling prevents a big mess later.

Making Ganache

Warm that cream just until tiny bubbles show up at the edges - not boiling, just hot enough to melt chocolate. When I first started making ganache, I'd get antsy and try to stir the chocolate too early. Now I know waiting untouched for a minute works better, melting the chocolate more smoothly. If your ganache looks too thin (like mine often does in summer), just let it sit for 5-10 minutes to thicken before putting it on your croissants.

Finishing Up

When spreading the chocolate topping, work fast before it hardens. I spoon from the middle, letting it flow naturally down the sides. Sometimes I guide it with the back of my spoon, pretending I'm on some cooking show where these details matter. Sprinkle nuts right away while the chocolate is still wet so they stick. I've had to chase many fallen nuts around my plate when I waited too long for this step.

My neighbor Tom, who says he hates "fancy desserts," ate three of these in one go last summer when he came over to return our lawn mower. His wife told me later that he mentioned "those cream-filled chocolate things" at least five times that week. Sometimes the best praise comes from the most unlikely sources.

Delightful Combinations

These go really well with fresh strawberries on the side - that bit of tartness cuts through all the richness perfectly. In my house, coffee is essential, especially strong black coffee that balances the sweetness. When I serve them for dessert after dinner, I sometimes offer a small glass of amaretto or Baileys, which works so well with the vanilla flavor. My kids always want big glasses of cold milk, showing that sometimes the traditional pairings can't be beaten.

Tasty Variations

You can add a dash of almond extract to the custard and top with toasted almonds for a nutty version my mother-in-law always asks for. During the holidays, I sometimes mix a tiny bit of peppermint extract into the ganache and sprinkle with crushed candy canes. Last summer I tried adding lemon zest to the custard and used white chocolate ganache instead - it tasted like sunshine and was gone before I could snap pics for our family cookbook.

Storage Tips

Truth be told - these hardly ever stick around long enough to need storing. But if you're making them ahead for visitors, the empty croissants can stay on the counter in a paper bag, and the custard can chill in the fridge for a couple days. Once put together, they'll stay good in the fridge for about a day before the croissants start getting too mushy. I sometimes make tiny versions for parties using those small cocktail croissants - they hold up better when filled and last a bit longer.

Pin it

I've brought these Boston Cream Pie Croissants to everything from book club gatherings to my son's teacher appreciation breakfast. They've become my go-to "I care enough to make something nice but not enough to spend forever in the kitchen" treat. The best part is watching people bite into them for the first time - there's always this moment when they realize it's not just an ordinary croissant. Even my pastry-snob cousin who trained in France said these were "not bad at all" - which in our family means they were absolutely fantastic.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I prepare these ahead of time?

Totally! Keep them in the fridge in an airtight container for up to a day so they stay fresh and soft.

→ Can I use boxed pudding instead of making custard?

Sure! Prepared vanilla pudding works fine, though making your own custard adds more flavor and texture.

→ How do I know my custard is ready?

It’s ready when it clings to the back of a spoon and a finger swipe leaves a clean line.

→ Will slightly old croissants work?

Yes, older croissants hold their shape better and are great for filling!

→ What if I don’t have a piping bag?

Snip the corner of a plastic bag or carefully use a small spoon to get the custard into the croissants.