Pin it
My family begs for these white chicken enchiladas almost weekly. I created them when regular red sauce versions got boring, and now they're a twice-monthly favorite. The mix of juicy chicken and gooey cheese tucked in soft tortillas and topped with that rich, tangy sauce makes comfort food that's fancy enough for guests but simple enough for busy evenings.
A few weeks back, I dropped these off for my neighbor after she had her baby. Her husband messaged me later saying it was her first complete meal since delivery, and wanted my recipe right away. When tired new moms clean their plates and ask how you made it, you've got something special.
Essential Components
- Cooked chicken: I grab rotisserie chicken for a time-saver, but any leftover bird works great. The store-bought seasoning adds nice background flavor.
- Monterey Jack cheese: It turns wonderfully gooey and has a subtle taste that works with the chilies without overwhelming them. Skip the bag stuff and grate it yourself for better melting.
- Sour cream: This creates that distinctive creamy tang in the sauce. Stick with regular for the best richness, though light can work if needed.
- Green chilies: They bring mild warmth and unique flavor that makes these stand out. Keep all the juice as it amps up the sauce taste.
- Flour tortillas: These stand up to creamy sauce better than corn ones, which tend to break down. Go for 8-inch ones for easy rolling.
Pin it
Enchilada Wisdom
- Chicken handling
- Pull the chicken apart instead of chopping it for better texture that soaks up more flavor. Just grab two forks and go at it.
- Rolling advice
- Don't pack too much inside or you'll end up with ripped shells and filling everywhere. About 2-3 spoonfuls per tortilla works great.
- Sauce tricks
- Your butter-flour mix needs a full minute of cooking time to get rid of that raw flour taste and make smooth sauce.
- Temperature control
- Take your pan off the heat before mixing in sour cream so it won't separate. The pot will still be warm enough to blend everything nicely.
- Cheese strategy
- Put cheese both in the filling and on top so every mouthful has that melty goodness.
- Baking signs
- Watch for bubbles around the edges and slightly golden cheese to know they're done. Toss foil on top if it browns too fast.
I came up with this after testing many versions. I started with cream of chicken soup but found it tasted too processed. Making sauce from scratch with butter and flour totally changed the flavor game. Putting green chilies in the sauce instead of the filling spreads their taste throughout every bite. My final improvement was switching from cheddar to Monterey Jack - it gets way meltier and matches the sauce perfectly.
Side Dish Matches
These rich enchiladas go great with a basic green salad topped with lime dressing to balance things out. For a full Mexican-style meal, add some cilantro lime rice and black beans alongside. Sprinkle fresh cilantro and diced tomatoes on top for color and bright flavors.
Fun Variations
Toss a cup of corn or black beans into your chicken mix for extra crunch and nutrients. Want more kick? Throw a chopped jalapeño in with your green chilies. Switch Monterey Jack for pepper jack cheese if you like things spicier.
Pin it
I've brought these white chicken enchiladas to tons of family dinners, community potlucks, and friends with new babies. There's something about that creamy, cheesy goodness that hits the spot every time. I love that they come together pretty quickly and I can adapt them based on what's in my kitchen - perfect for nights when I want something special without spending hours cooking.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I get these ready in advance?
- Totally! Set them up and keep the sauce separate in the fridge for up to a day. When you’re ready, pour the sauce on top and bake. Add about 5-10 extra minutes if they start cold.
- → What’s the simplest way to shred chicken?
- Grab a rotisserie chicken for ease. If you’re starting from scratch, simmer chicken breasts in broth or poach them. Shred warm chicken with two forks or use a mixer with the paddle attachment for speed.
- → Can I freeze these enchiladas?
- Absolutely! Assemble and skip the sauce if freezing before baking. Wrap and freeze. Thaw overnight, then add sauce before baking. If freezing after cooking, cool fully first, then wrap and freeze.
- → What works instead of green chilies?
- No green chilies? Swap for diced jalapeños (seeds out if you want less spice), roasted poblano peppers, or even a little salsa verde.
- → What should I serve with these enchiladas?
- They’re great with Mexican rice, black beans, a quick green salad, or guac. Brighten your meal with lime wedges on the side!