Pin it
I stumbled upon these Italian cream stuffed cannoncini while traveling in northern Italy and they've now become my go-to fancy dessert when hosting dinner. I've spent ages trying to nail that magical mix of buttery, crisp pastry shell with smooth vanilla filling. What I love most is how the flaky, sugar-coated outside breaks against the cool, silky cream filling – it's simply divine.
When I made these instead of traditional cookies at our family Christmas gathering last year, my grandma (who never praises anyone else's cooking) asked me how to make them before heading home. That told me everything I needed to know.
Essential Components
- Puff pastry: Don't feel bad about buying pre-made - it works great and cuts down prep time. Just pick the all-butter kind for better taste.
- Egg yolks: They're what makes your custard deeply colored and smooth. The leftover whites can make a nice breakfast omelet!
- Vanilla extract: Skip the fake stuff. Want to make it extra fancy? Scrape in real vanilla bean seeds.
- Sugar for rolling: This creates that sweet, crunchy outside that'll keep you coming back for more.
- Horn molds: No proper molds? No problem. You can roll some aluminum foil into cone shapes.
Pin it
Delightful Pastry Techniques
- Master your custard
- Getting smooth custard means never stopping your stirring and staying patient. Keep heat low to medium and keep that whisk moving, especially when it starts getting thick. This stops any lumps from forming.
- Cool stuff, hot outcome
- Your puff pastry should be cool but easy to work with. If it gets too soft while you're cutting it, stick it back in the fridge. Cool dough makes flakier pastry.
- Double sugar coating
- Make sure you use plenty of sugar when rolling the dough. That sugar turns golden brown in the oven, giving you that wonderful sweet crunch cannoncini are known for.
- Tuck the end under
- Always put your pastry horns with the strip end facing down on your baking tray. This stops them from coming unwrapped while baking.
- Watch your egg wash
- When brushing with egg, try not to let it run between the mold and pastry or they'll stick together. Just brush the parts you can see.
- Take your time removing molds
- Let everything cool a bit before trying to take out the molds. If they're stuck, try pressing the metal mold in slightly to help it come loose.
I got these recipes from an old lady in my apartment building who came to America from Milan back in the 60s. She'd make them for special events, and after trying my first one, I begged her to teach me. She showed me exactly how to wrap the pastry around the molds and when to know the custard was done just right. After she died a few years back, I baked a batch for her memorial - it felt like the perfect way to remember her.
Presentation Thoughts
These work great on a fancy dessert table with some fresh berries and small coffee cups. Try adding a tiny stream of dark chocolate over the cream ends for extra flair. They're perfect for fancy brunches or tea parties when you want something that looks impressive but isn't too heavy.
Flavor Variations
Mix a spoonful of hazelnut spread into your custard for a Nutella twist. Or try adding lemon zest and a bit of juice for a fresh, tangy version. Want something more grown-up? Stir a tablespoon of Grand Marnier or Frangelico into your cream.
Keeping It Fresh
Empty pastry horns stay good in a sealed container at room temp for up to two days. Your custard will last in the fridge for about three days. Don't ever store them after filling - they'll turn mushy! Always add the cream right before serving to keep that amazing crisp-meets-creamy contrast.
Pin it
I've brought these Italian cream stuffed cannoncini to so many events - dinner parties, holiday get-togethers, and fancy brunches. There's something about setting down a plate of these elegant treats that makes any gathering feel extra special. Watching friends take that first bite - when the pastry crunches and cream oozes out - brings me so much joy when sharing food with people I care about.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Where can I get cannoncini molds?
- Check local kitchenware stores or online shops for cream horn molds or cannoli forms. You can also make your own by shaping foil into cones, though they might not be as consistent.
- → How far in advance can I prepare these?
- You can make the shells and custard a day or two early. Keep them separate and only fill the cones when you're ready to serve so the pastry stays crisp.
- → How do I handle lumpy custard?
- Warm custard with lumps can be fixed by pushing it through a fine mesh strainer. To avoid lumps altogether, whisk constantly and slowly add the hot milk while cooking.
- → Can I skip making homemade custard?
- You can use store-bought custard if you're short on time. Just pick a thick, high-quality pastry cream or pudding for the best results.
- → What are some other filling ideas?
- Experiment with chocolate or coffee custard, whipped cream with fruit, or even hazelnut spread for tasty alternatives.