Pin it
Make your home feel like a fancy donut place with these yummy heart donuts filled with strawberry cheesecake cream. After trying many times to copy my fave bakery's stuffed treats, I finally cracked the code for making super light brioche that's crunchy outside and soft inside. Though these cute hearts work great for Valentine's Day, I find myself whipping them up all year because they're just too tasty to save for once a year.
I got hooked on donuts when I found out homemade ones could actually taste better than store-bought - if you know what you're doing. After lots of messy kitchen sessions and plenty of sampling, this turned out to be my winning recipe.
Key Ingredients Breakdown
- Mixed Flours: Using both bread and all-purpose flour gives you just the right texture
- Active Dry Yeast: Makes sure your donuts puff up nicely
- Freeze-dried Strawberries: The trick for getting strong strawberry flavor
- Full-fat Cream Cheese: Adds that wonderful cheesecake zip
- Whole Milk: Helps make everything soft and tender
Pin it
Making Your Treats
- Getting The Dough Right:
- You'll know your donuts will turn out great when the dough feels smooth and stretchy after kneading. I learned through practice that the window test works every time: if you can stretch a bit of dough thin enough to see through without it breaking, you've got the gluten just right.
- Letting It Grow:
- Don't rush the rising step. I found out the hard way that hurried donuts end up heavy. When you poke the dough gently, it should leave a small dent that slowly comes back up - kind of like pressing a ripe fruit.
My biggest aha moment was when I stopped thinking about donut-making as following strict rules and started using my senses. You'll learn to tell when the dough feels just right, and to hear when it hits the oil with that perfect sound.
Mastering The Cooking
The sweet spot is between 350-360°F - this isn't just a random number, it's where everything comes together. Too hot and you'll get golden outsides but raw middles; too cool and they'll soak up too much oil. I keep one special tool just for pulling out my donuts.
Trying Different Flavors
Strawberry cheesecake filling tastes amazing, but you can play around with this recipe. Sometimes I'll use vanilla bean cream instead, other times I go with chocolate spread or lemon filling. The base recipe works so well that it handles changes beautifully.
Keeping Them Fresh
Truth be told - these taste best right away. While they'll stay good for a day in a sealed container, nothing beats a warm, freshly filled donut. You can make the dough the night before and keep it in the fridge to fry in the morning.
Pin it
Insider Cook Tricks
- Put small parchment squares under each donut while they rise
- Keep your oil at the same temperature by cooking just a few at a time
- Add the filling just before you eat them for the best texture
- Don't throw away the donut holes - they're perfect for sampling
What began as a Valentine's treat has become my go-to recipe, asked for at breakfast gatherings, parties, and random weekday mornings when only a fresh donut will hit the spot. They show that some of the tastiest baking happens when you mix good technique with a bit of love.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Can I prep the dough early?
- Sure, you can refrigerate the dough overnight after the first rise. Let it warm up before shaping.
- → Why is oil temp so important?
- Keeping the oil at 350-360°F makes sure donuts fry evenly and stay crispy, not oily.
- → Can fresh strawberries work?
- Not really. Freeze-dried ones pack flavor without watering down the filling.
- → How to tell if dough's ready?
- Do the windowpane test. Stretch a small bit of dough, and if it’s thin enough for light to pass through without tearing, it’s good to go.
- → Can I bake these instead?
- These are meant to be fried for the texture. Baking them won't give you the same fluffy result.