Creamy Rice Comfort

Each velvety bite of rice pudding offers pure comfort, blending the humble trio of rice, milk, and aromatic spices. This laid-back Colombian-style treat ditches fancy methods for straightforward, heartwarming goodness that'll take you back to family kitchens of your childhood—whether you actually had this treat growing up or not.

When I whipped this up for the first time, my doubtful partner (who swore rice pudding wasn't his thing) couldn't help grabbing another serving, then one more after that. The subtle vanilla mixed with warm cinnamon notes and that silky-smooth texture changed his mind completely. These days, it's what he asks for most when the weather turns cold.

Cozy Essential Components

• Medium grain rice delivers that just-right foundation—striking the perfect balance between firm and soft with that satisfying tender chew that defines amazing rice pudding
• Milk builds the luscious base that turns ordinary grains into something special—feel free to use whatever you've got, from full-fat to non-fat or plant-based options if you're skipping dairy
• Sugar adds just enough sweetness without going overboard—regular granulated works great but swap in your preferred sweetener if needed
• Cinnamon brings that cozy, familiar warmth that makes each spoonful feel like comfort—sprinkle in ground or drop in a stick for gentle flavor
• Vanilla extract (the genuine stuff) adds richness that transforms the whole dish—this ingredient really deserves the good stuff
• Raisins scatter little sweet surprises throughout—totally skip them if you want, but they do add that classic touch many people love
• Condensed milk might surprise you but it's actually the hidden hero adding incredible richness and depth
• Butter gives that final luxurious touch that pulls everything together with a smooth, rich mouthfeel you'll crave

Pin it

Soothing Preparation Steps

Everything In One Pot

Throw your rice, milk, sugar, cinnamon and vanilla into a sturdy pot with a thick bottom. This simple approach lets the rice soak up all the flavors right from the start. You won't need to juggle multiple pots or cook anything separately—the beauty lies in keeping things uncomplicated.

Slow And Steady Cooking

Get your mixture going with a soft simmer over medium heat, giving it a stir now and then so nothing sticks. Don't crank up the flame—you want tiny bubbles just barely breaking the surface, not a wild boil. This unhurried approach helps the rice slowly release starch into the milk, creating that signature creaminess without burning.

Take Your Time

Keep cooking and stir more often as things get thicker to stop any rice from gluing itself to the pot. This is relaxed cooking—the kind where you can have a chat, drink something warm, or just breathe in the amazing smells filling your kitchen. You'll see the mixture slowly change right before you.

Finishing Moves

Once your rice feels soft and the mix has thickened how you like it, add the condensed milk, butter, and raisins if you want them. These last bits turn good pudding into something you won't forget. The condensed milk adds a sweet, almost caramel-like flavor, while butter makes everything wonderfully smooth.

Let It Settle

Pull the pot off the heat and give your creation a moment to chill out before digging in. This short break lets the pudding firm up slightly and the flavors come together perfectly. Enjoy it warm with maybe a light sprinkle of cinnamon on top, or cool it down for a totally different but equally tasty experience.

I've cooked this pudding through all four seasons, but there's something extra special about making it when rain taps against the windows. The kitchen gets all steamy, that sweet vanilla-cinnamon smell spreads everywhere, and suddenly my problems don't seem so big anymore. My aunt always made this whenever someone felt sick—she claimed it worked better than medicine. After she passed down her special pot just for rice pudding, I never use anything else for this recipe.

Ways To Enjoy

Scoop this creamy treat straight from the warm pot for the ultimate comfort feeling, maybe with an extra dash of cinnamon scattered over top. For something special at breakfast, pull chilled pudding from the fridge and top with some fresh berries or banana slices for a morning treat that feels fancy but still wholesome. During festive times, try spooning portions into cute little glasses, topped with a tiny grating of nutmeg and a cinnamon stick for a simple yet impressive dessert option.

Tasty Twists

Try new flavor combinations by tossing in some orange zest while cooking for a fresh citrus kick that works amazingly with the cinnamon. For a summer vibe, swap some milk for coconut milk and mix in chopped mango instead of raisins—perfect for warmer evenings. When leaves start falling, try mixing in a spoonful of pumpkin puree with a pinch of pumpkin spice for a seasonal twist you might end up loving even more than the original.

Keeping It Fresh

Your pudding will stay good in a sealed container in the fridge for about four days, though at my place it never hangs around that long. If it gets too thick after cooling, just stir in a splash of milk before warming it up on the stove or in the microwave. For easy snacks, pour it into small containers while still warm so you can grab them for quick breakfasts or snacks throughout your week.

Pin it

Useful Cooking Tricks

• Make sure you scrape the bottom when stirring, especially as things get thicker, so rice doesn't stick and burn
• Don't try to speed things up—that slow cooking really builds the flavor and gets you that perfect smooth texture
• Give it a taste before adding the final ingredients so you can adjust the sweetness to your liking—everyone's preference differs

Back when I was little, rice pudding meant rainy days were coming. Mom would start cooking whenever dark clouds rolled in, and soon the sweet smell would pull everyone to the kitchen like a magnet. She always told me to watch for when the wooden spoon could stand straight up in the pot on its own—that's when you knew it was just right. Now with my own kids, I find myself reaching for the rice bag whenever it looks stormy outside, keeping alive a simple family tradition that somehow makes gloomy days brighter. Because really, isn't that what comfort food does best?

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What milk works best for this dish?

You have options! Use whole milk, skim, low-fat, or mix in a splash of cream for extra richness.

→ Should I pre-cook the rice?

Nope! Start with raw rice. It soaks up flavors better and gives the dish that perfect texture.

→ Can I skip raisins?

Sure! Raisins are optional. Switch them out with dried cranberries or apricots, or leave them out entirely.

→ When is it ready?

The rice should be tender and the mixture should be rich and creamy. Take it off the stove when it’s a bit runnier than you want—it thickens as it cools.

→ Is it good cold?

Yep! It’s great both warm or chilled. If served cold, expect it to be a little thicker.