Colorful Easter Cake

I found this Easter poke cake by accident when trying to come up with something cool but quick for our family get-together last spring. When you mix that swirly, multicolored cake with smooth pudding inside and that airy whipped topping, you get this amazing treat that looks fancy but doesn't take much work. Now we make it every Easter, and honestly, making it is almost as fun as eating it.

When my brother's wife watched me throw this together last Easter, she couldn't believe how easy it was and asked me to write down the steps right away. It's funny how the quickest recipes often get the biggest reactions, especially when they look as pretty as this cake does.

Basic Elements

• White cake mix - Works as your clean slate for adding those beautiful soft colors
• Greek yogurt - My little trick that gives you an extra tender, juicy cake texture
• Gel food coloring - Packs more color punch without making your batter too thin
• Instant pudding - Flows into those poked spots to make hidden pockets of creaminess
• Fresh whipped cream - That soft, cloud-like finish that brings everything together

Pin it

Delightful Assembly

Mix Prep

Mixing Greek yogurt into your cake box stuff makes it way softer and juicier than just doing what the box says. I mix it for the whole two minutes to get air in there, which helps the cake puff up nicely. When I split the batter, I grab a measuring cup so each bowl gets the same amount for even colors. Trust me, use gel coloring instead of the liquid stuff - you'll get those bright Easter colors without turning your batter all runny. I always start with just a tiny dot and then add more until I see those pretty spring shades.

Swirl Method

For those pretty swirls, just drop spoonfuls of each color randomly and don't worry too much about making a pattern. I put random blobs of each color all over the pan, making sure they touch. Then just run a knife through it lightly. The first time I tried this, I mixed too much and ended up with a weird brownish-purple mess. Now I just do a few easy swirls and stop. Every cake comes out looking different, which is actually part of what makes it special.

Making Holes

A wooden spoon handle makes just the right size holes for pudding to sink in. I put them about an inch from each other all over, right to the edges. I wiggle the handle a bit to make the holes a little wider without tearing up the cake. I've learned to poke about two-thirds down so there's still some solid cake at the bottom but plenty of room for pudding to soak in. Don't worry if the holes look too big - once they're filled with pudding, they'll create those tasty little pudding spots.

Pudding Pour

You gotta work fast after you mix the pudding because it starts getting thick quickly. I pour it over right away, focusing on filling the holes first, then spread what's left across the top. I use a rubber scraper to push pudding into the holes to make sure they get filled up good. Then it goes in the fridge so the pudding can set and soak into the cake, making that awesome texture that's somewhere between cake and pudding. Sometimes I add a tiny bit of the same food coloring to the pudding to make it even more festive.

Cream Topping

Whip your cream until it stands up in stiff peaks so it stays fluffy but doesn't fall flat. I always chill my bowl and beaters in the freezer first to help it whip up bigger. The sugar dissolves as you beat it, making a lightly sweet topping that works perfectly with the sweeter cake and pudding underneath. I usually add a little vanilla to the cream for extra flavor. Make sure to spread it all the way to the edges to seal in moisture.

Fun Decorations

The coconut sprinkled on top looks like grass and adds a nice crunch too. For more fun, I sometimes mix a drop of green food coloring with some coconut to make it look more like Easter grass. Adding those seasonal sprinkles and little chocolate eggs makes it look like an Easter basket that kids go crazy for. I group the decorations in little clusters instead of scattering them everywhere, which makes it look like I bought it from a fancy bakery.

Last Easter, my picky niece actually helped me put this cake together, carefully placing chocolate eggs on top in patterns. She was so excited about how it turned out that she told everyone which part she decorated. Those moments when kids get involved in the kitchen often turn into the best holiday memories.

Tasty Companions

This fun cake tastes great with a hot cup of coffee or tea in the afternoon. It can be the star dessert at your Easter dinner table with some fresh fruit on the side for a lighter option. Some folks like to add a scoop of vanilla ice cream for an extra treat. My children always want it with big glasses of cold milk for their after-dinner sweet.

Mix It Up Ideas

Go for chocolate cake with chocolate pudding if you've got chocolate fans in your house. Switch the vanilla pudding for lemon or coconut flavors to change things up. Try putting a layer of fresh berries between the pudding and whipped cream for a fruity kick. Last year I played around with different flavors in the whipped cream - the almond extract worked really well with the vanilla pudding.

Pin it

I've brought this Easter poke cake to family dinners, church gatherings, and school functions, and it always gets people smiling. There's just something special about those colorful swirls mixed with creamy pudding and fluffy topping that everybody loves. My daughter now helps me make it each Easter, carefully dropping in the colored batters and fixing up the top. We're building a sweet tradition that I hope she'll carry on with her own family someday. The recipes that really stick with us are often the ones that bring us together - both in the kitchen and around the table.

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I try a different cake mix?

Of course! Yellow or vanilla works well. Just know darker mixes won't keep the pastel look as well.

→ How early can I prep this cake?

You can make it 1-2 days in advance. If making it a day early, Cool Whip holds up better than fresh whipped cream.

→ Can I just use liquid food coloring?

Yes, but gel coloring creates stronger shades and doesn't thin out your batter. Liquid requires more drops to get similar results.

→ Why's the center of my cake mushy?

Let the cake cool fully before adding pudding. Also, keep the holes small and spaced-out to prevent sogginess.

→ Can I freeze leftover cake?

It's not ideal since thawing messes with the whipped topping and pudding's texture.

→ Any other topping ideas for this cake?

Totally! Add jelly beans, pastel M&Ms, crushed Cadbury eggs, or any fun Easter candy you like.